A family may know that a loved one signed a will but discover only a photocopy after the person dies. Perhaps the original was kept in a home safe, moved during a relocation, or left with an attorney whose office has since changed.
A missing original creates a legal question that deserves prompt attention. It does not automatically mean the family can use a copy without further proof. It also does not mean that every missing-will situation has the same outcome.
For Illinois families, the practical starting point is to preserve what exists, document a careful search, and obtain legal guidance before distributing estate property.
Why the Original Matters
A signed original helps establish the document the person executed. When it cannot be found, questions can arise about its contents, execution, custody, and whether the person intended to revoke it.
In In re Estate of Frakes, 2020 IL App (3d) 180649, the Illinois Appellate Court discussed the presumption of revocation associated with a missing will last traced to the deceased person’s possession. Evidence can rebut that presumption. The court affirmed admission of a conformed copy in a case involving evidence that the original had been stolen.
The decision does not establish that every photocopy will be accepted or that an allegation of theft is enough. The circumstances and available proof matter. An attorney should evaluate how the governing law applies to the particular document and its history.
First Distinguish Two Different Situations
If you are searching for your own will while you are alive, contact your estate planning attorney. Explain where you last kept it and whether you have copies or amendments. Discuss a properly documented solution rather than leaving the problem for your family.
If someone has already died, preserve all available versions and seek advice about estate administration. Family members cannot resolve the issue by signing the deceased person’s name on a new printout or deciding among themselves which version should count.
This article focuses on a conventional paper will. If the plan involved an electronically executed will, tell the attorney so the relevant records and requirements can be considered.
Conduct a Careful, Documented Search
Start with locations the person actually used for important records. Possibilities include a home filing system, safe, document box, or the office that prepared the plan. Ask about access rights before attempting to open a safe deposit box or obtain another person’s private records.
Create a search log recording:
- The location checked and the date.
- Who conducted the search.
- Whether a copy, original, or amendment was found.
- Who was contacted about custody of the original.
- Any information about a move, fire, theft, or damaged records.
Do not assume the drafting attorney still holds the original. Ask the office what its records show about delivery or storage. If the attorney retired or the practice changed, ask whether there is a successor or a designated records contact.
Keep the search factual. “We checked the home office on Tuesday and found a signed photocopy” is more useful than an unsupported conclusion about what someone must have done.
Preserve Copies, Correspondence, and Amendments

Keep each document in the condition in which you found it. Avoid writing on it, discarding pages, separating attachments, or assembling different versions into what looks like a single original.
Useful materials to show an attorney may include:
- Photocopies or scans of the signed will.
- Earlier wills and documents labeled as amendments.
- Letters or emails from the drafting office.
- Receipts or correspondence about document storage.
- Information identifying witnesses or other people present at signing.
- Records of an event that may explain the document’s disappearance.
An amendment deserves attention even if the family thinks the main will is unchanged. LaCava’s explanation of codicils in Illinois explains why the will and later amendments need to be considered together.
What If an Original Turns Up After the Death?
Illinois law imposes a filing duty. Under 755 ILCS 5/6-1, a person possessing the testator’s will must file it with the clerk of the proper county immediately upon the testator’s death.
Do not assume that keeping the original in a family folder satisfies that requirement. Ask counsel or the appropriate clerk about the filing process and retain confirmation of what was filed.
Filing a document and having it admitted to probate are separate steps. Section 6-4 of the Illinois Probate Act addresses proof for admission, including witness statements and other competent evidence. Which proof is needed in a missing-original situation requires a case-specific assessment.
If a document is found after another version has already been submitted, notify the estate attorney promptly. Do not quietly replace it in the file or assume the later discovery has no effect.
Avoid Distributing Property Based Only on Family Agreement
While the issue is being evaluated, keep a clear inventory of estate property and relevant records. Ask counsel what steps are appropriate to safeguard assets and handle expenses, and who has authority to act.
Being named as executor in a copy does not answer every question about immediate authority. LaCava’s guide to an executor’s role in Illinois provides background for that discussion.
Also bring information about trusts, account ownership, and beneficiary designations. A missing will should be assessed alongside the full estate plan, rather than treated as proof that every asset must follow the same transfer process.
For that related issue, read whether beneficiary designations override a will.
A Hypothetical Family Example
Suppose a parent tells two adult children that the signed will is in a home safe. After the parent’s death, they find a scanned copy on a computer but no paper original.
One child remembers a recent move. The other remembers that the parent met with an attorney afterward. Neither knows whether a new will was signed.
The useful next step is to collect those facts, preserve the scan, contact the drafting office, and document the search. It would be premature to conclude either that the scan must control or that the parent intentionally canceled the plan.
The example illustrates why a timeline helps. Dates, document custody, and information about later planning can give counsel a more reliable starting point than a family vote about what seems fair.
Build a Timeline Without Filling Gaps With Assumptions
Separate what someone personally observed from what they heard later. Identify who last saw the original, when that happened, and where it was kept at that time. Record uncertainty honestly.
An attorney may need to distinguish a document that disappeared during the person’s lifetime from one misplaced while belongings were being sorted after death. Information about access to the storage location can also help explain what is known and what remains unresolved.
Avoid accusations based only on a beneficiary’s financial interest or a disagreement within the family. Preserve relevant messages and records, and let counsel assess their legal significance. A documented fact is more useful than a confident theory with no supporting evidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a scan useless if the original is missing?
No. Preserve it. A copy may be relevant evidence, but its existence alone does not settle whether it can be admitted or what additional proof is required.
Does a missing original always mean there is no valid will?
No. The circumstances require legal analysis. Avoid assuming a result before the document history and evidence have been reviewed.
Can a relative sign a replacement after the person dies?
No. Do not attempt to recreate the deceased person’s signature or execute a new will for them. Obtain advice about the proper court process.
What should I bring to an initial consultation?
Bring every version found, related correspondence, a search log, and a timeline of what is known about signing and storage. Identify uncertainties rather than guessing.
Get Guidance Before Making Assumptions
A missing original will can affect the family’s next steps, but an organized search and preserved records provide a better foundation for legal advice.
Contact LaCava Law Firm in Geneva to discuss your Illinois estate planning or document concerns. This article provides general information, not advice about a particular estate or a prediction of a court’s decision.
